Guide
Digital vs Physical Gift Cards: Which Sells for More?
Digital vs Physical Gift Cards
Gift cards come in two forms: digital (e-gift cards sent by email) and physical (plastic cards purchased in stores). Each has advantages and disadvantages when it comes to resale.
Digital Gift Cards (E-Gift Cards)
Pros for Selling
- ✅ Instant delivery — no shipping or handling needed.
- ✅ Code is already in digital format — easy to verify.
- ✅ No physical damage or wear issues.
- ✅ Often come with purchase receipts in email.
Cons for Selling
- ❌ Higher fraud risk — digital codes are easier to duplicate.
- ❌ May require additional verification steps.
- ❌ Some platforms offer slightly lower rates for digital codes.
Physical Gift Cards
Pros for Selling
- ✅ Lower fraud risk — physical possession proves ownership.
- ✅ Can take photos as proof (front and back).
- ✅ Purchase receipts are common (gift-givers often include them).
- ✅ Slightly higher rates on some platforms.
Cons for Selling
- ❌ Must photograph clearly (blurry images delay verification).
- ❌ Scratch-off PIN areas can be damaged if not careful.
- ❌ Shipping is not required but may be requested for very high-value cards.
Rate Comparison
| Brand | Physical Card Rate | Digital Card Rate |
|---|---|---|
| Amazon | 82-90% | 80-88% |
| Apple/iTunes | 80-88% | 78-86% |
| Steam | 75-85% | 72-83% |
| Google Play | 77-85% | 75-83% |
Physical cards typically earn 2-3% more due to lower fraud risk.
Which Should You Sell?
If you have both types: Physical cards generally get slightly better rates. But the difference is small (2-3%), so convenience matters too.
Our recommendation: Sell whichever you have — both types are accepted and processed quickly. The rate difference is not significant enough to delay selling.
Check your card rate → Get an Instant Quote